Is the 4% Rule Still Safe? Retirement Withdrawal Strategy Explained

The 4% Rule offers a simple plan for long-term retirement income. But is it still reliable today? Learn how it works and see if it fits your strategy. Curious? Check below to dive in.



1️⃣ What Is the 4% Rule?

The 4% Rule was introduced by financial advisor William Bengen in 1994. It suggests that retirees can withdraw 4% of their portfolio in the first year of retirement, then adjust that amount for inflation annually. This strategy was historically proven to last through even the worst economic downturns.

2️⃣ A Real-World Example: $1.25M Portfolio

If you retire with $1,250,000 at age 62:

  • Year 1: $50,000 withdrawal (4%)
  • Year 2: $51,500 withdrawal (if inflation = 3%)
  • Year 3 and beyond: Continue inflation adjustments

It creates a stable and predictable income stream — simple and effective.

3️⃣ What Are the Assumptions?

  • 50% stock (e.g., S&P 500 index)
  • 50% intermediate government bonds
  • Annual rebalancing
  • Buy and hold — no market timing

This setup performed well historically — even during market crashes.

4️⃣ Should You Stick with 4%?

Some retirees find 4% too conservative. Others worry it’s too aggressive in today's market. Here’s what recent research suggests:

  • Ultra-conservative: 3.5–3.8%
  • Balanced: 4.0–4.2%
  • Growth-focused: 4.5%+

5️⃣ Market-Based Adjustments

Market Condition Recommended Withdrawal Rate
Overvalued (Shiller P/E > 25) 3.5–3.8%
Fair Value (P/E 15–25) 4.0–4.2%
Undervalued (P/E < 15) 4.5–5.0%

6️⃣ Real-Life Scenario: Meet James and Karen

James and Karen retire with $1.25M. In Year 1, they withdraw $50,000. When markets dip in Year 3, they reduce spending to $42,000. When markets recover, they increase to $52,000. Their flexibility helps preserve their portfolio without stress.

7️⃣ Final Thoughts

The 4% Rule is a guide — not a guarantee. It's an excellent starting point for financial planning, offering clarity and confidence.

  • ✔️ Adjust for inflation
  • ✔️ Watch market trends
  • ✔️ Be ready to adapt

Start with 4%, then make it your own.



Previous Post Next Post